Size comparisonsJumbo vs Regular Butter Squishy: Which Size Fits?
Use dimensions and your own routine to compare smaller and larger butter-inspired toys.
A little more on thisA LITTLE SIDE BY SIDE
A little side by side.
Regular or jumbo? Butter or cheese? Compare the retailer prices and details to find your kind of squish.
Make it your kind of comparison.
Choose up to three styles and put the available details side by side.
| The little details |  Butter Squishy 4 oz | Jumbo Butter Squishy 14 oz |  Cheese Squishy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shape & listing | A butter-stick shape | Comparing the jumbo listing | A different food-inspired shape |
| Size label | 4 oz in the product name; dimensions not published | 14 oz in the product name; dimensions not published | Dimensions not published |
| Retailer-stated material | PU foam, according to the retailer | PU foam, according to the retailer | PU foam, according to the retailer |
| Retailer-stated texture | Slow-rising, according to the retailer | Slow-rising, according to the retailer | Slow-rising, according to the retailer |
| Listed price (USD) | $14.99Buttersquishy · checked Nov 3, 2026 | $19.99Buttersquishy · checked Nov 3, 2026 | $18.99Buttersquishy · checked Nov 3, 2026 |
| Tax & shipping may apply. | Read our guide | Read our guide | Read our guide |
3 stories to explore
Size comparisonsShape comparisonsButter Squishy vs Other Food Squishies
Compare butter sticks, bread, fruit, and cheese shapes using the details that actually affect your choice.
A little more on thisProduct comparisonsButter Squishy vs NeeDoh: Compare Exact Products
A shape theme and a branded toy range need a product-by-product comparison.
A little more on thisA softer way to shop, with clearer information.
Start with our Butter Squishy guide or check how our research works.